19 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
MPC's avatar

It's like I said a few weeks ago, Reynolds having to defend DOGE and job losses in the farming industry to angry Iowans next year wouldn't be good for her.

Expand full comment
David Nir's avatar

Might not go too well for Ernst either...

Expand full comment
MPC's avatar

I am praying, crossing my fingers, manifesting and doing a lot of letter writing via Vote Forward to get things turned around next year.

Ernst losing her seat next year (as well as Tillis and Collins) would be richly deserved. And if any other shock R-to-D Senate flips happen next year, I welcome it.

Expand full comment
Burt Kloner's avatar

1980: deja vu all over again in the opposite direction.

Expand full comment
Laura Belin's avatar

It is really hard to see how Democrats can beat Ernst next year. The last sitting U.S. senator to lose a re-election bid in Iowa was Roger Jepsen, who lost to Tom Harkin in 1984. And the GOP voter registration advantage in Iowa is very large now.

But I'm glad to see credible Democratic candidates planning to run for Senate because if the bottom falls out for Ernst, who knows?

Expand full comment
Guy's avatar

And of course itтАЩs bad news for Miller-Meeks and Nunn, and maybe even Hinson will have a race on her hands next year.

Expand full comment
Zero Cool's avatar

Ernst performed several percentage points lower in 2020 than Trump did when he beat Biden in the state. Her re-election margin of victory dropped by nearly 2% points from her Senate election back in the 2014 midterms.

2014

https://www.nytimes.com/elections/2014/iowa-elections

2020

https://www.politico.com/2020-election/results/iowa/senate/

Expand full comment
PollJunkie's avatar

Not sure, you can't win Iowa without white working class voters and we have totally lost them since Obama.

Republicans won Iowa by healthy margins in both 2018 blue wave and 2020.

Expand full comment
David Nir's avatar

The 2018 Gov race was less than 3 pts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Iowa_gubernatorial_election

Expand full comment
PollJunkie's avatar

Even though Hubbell was the favorite before the election.

Republicans also found more success downballot with a similar turnout other than Rob. Another reason I am skeptical is because of the increased polarization and even lesser ticket splitting today. Republican cuts may turn off rural areas but we'll have to see.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_Iowa_elections

Expand full comment
David Nir's avatar

Sure, the (limited number) of polls were mostly off, but you can't call 3 points a "healthy margin"!

Expand full comment
PollJunkie's avatar

Yes.

Expand full comment
Laura Belin's avatar

I think Reynolds would have been strongly favored to be re-elected in 2026. The Republican voter registration advantage in Iowa is massive now, around 175,000. No-party turnout craters in midterm elections so even with strong D turnout and winning independents, very hard to get to a win number in a statewide election.

Expand full comment
MPC's avatar

If the D Senate candidate peels off a small percentage of Iowan Republican voters ticked off by DOGE and job losses, is it possible to flip it?

Expand full comment
Laura Belin's avatar

Very challenging. It would have to be a 1974 level wave.

Expand full comment
Voter1919's avatar

In 2018, 2020, and 2022, Iowa Republicans indeed turned respectable victories in statewide races, but I must say that across all three cycles -- it wasn't the North Korea-style margins that we often see in other red states. In fact, we have almost won a lot of these cycles, despite oftentimes running B/C tier candidates. Even when we didn't win, the base still blocked them from anything higher than the mid to upper 50s in terms of percentage. So I think under the right environment and with the right candidates (and the right resources and funding), Iowa Democrats can surprise us next year.

Expand full comment
Laura Belin's avatar

The voter registration numbers are much worse for Democrats now than in 2018 or 2020.

Expand full comment
Sam Carson's avatar

I'm not really seeing how Laura Belin's pundit tsk-tsking is helping anybody.

Expand full comment
Alyssa's avatar

She wouldnтАЩt survive plus her drinking habit has been bad for a long time

Expand full comment