10 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
ClimateHawk's avatar

That's close to how I'd view it.

Very good: MI

Good: WI, NV

Better than OK: PA, NC

Tossup: AZ, GA

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

Very good:MI, WI

Good: NV

Better than Ok:PA, AZ

Tossup:NC, GA

Expand full comment
michaelflutist's avatar

What would account for a better performance in Wisconsin than Pennsylvania?

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

Not speaking for climate hawk, but imo Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania will eventually vote all the same way(with marginal differences)

Expand full comment
michaelflutist's avatar

Last time, Wisconsin was the closest, with a substantial margin between them and Pennsylvania, at least in terms of raw votes, but of course Pennsylvania is a much more populous state.

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

I am going to work backwards and see the last time that they didn't vote the same(I honestly can't recall, so might be telling); and then I will post

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

In 1988 the 3 didn't vote the same; imo the pattern will be same this year

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

And the time before that was 1976; interesting to me is that in 1976, Carter won Pennsylvania, and lost New Jersey and Connecticut(had Carter lost Pennsylvania, the electoral college would have been Carter 270\Ford 267; there was a faithless elector I assume)

Expand full comment
safik's avatar

I can see how you get to a 3-4 point win in Wisconsin, Trump has largely crested in the rural areas, the suburbs continue to turn blue and the Dane population growth continues. I think if you get that, even with a slight improvement in PA, you could still very easily have a bigger margin in WI than PA.

Expand full comment
ClimateHawk's avatar

For me, a couple things.

1) State chair Ben Wikler is the best Dem chair in the country, IMHO.

2) WI Dems, after taking back the state SCT, and getting fair districts for the state (but not Congressional!) lines, really have a shot at taking back the state Assembly and have a shot to make Senate 8nroads as well.

3) Kamala spent some time Madison as a child. A chance to vote for one of your own usually helps.

4) Walz will have a bit more impact in WI than PA.

Expand full comment
ErrorError