15 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
CuriousReader4456's avatar

David Shor published an analysis that Trump would have won by 5 points if every registered voter turned out. Dems have done great recently in super low turnout specials.

Very hard to tell what exact turnout number is best for dems. Though lower overall is likely better.

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

i dont believe that analysis at all

Expand full comment
LiberalBuffalo's avatar

Why? Because your bias tells you so?

Trump turns out nonregular voters. That fact is by now indisputable no matter how much you don't want to hear it.

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

since i have zero bias, i have zero idea what you are talking about; but, i think that analysis is clearly flawed

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

just because YOU state something doesnt make it a fact; just sayin

Expand full comment
Mark's avatar

Based on what?

Expand full comment
Mark's avatar

Yep. My question was directed to Jonathan. NBC's final poll--which came as close as any media poll to nailing it--also showed that low-propensity voters were overwhelmingly leaning Trump. Voters whose likelihood to vote ranked at 9 or 10 were tied in that poll. Voters whose likelihood to vote was ranked at 7 or 8 were going Harris +2. And the voters who were at 6 or less for likelihood to vote supported Trump +16. Shor's findings were absolutely consistent with that.

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

imo Millions of Biden voters stayed home; Harris lost by about 250,000 in 3 states that matter; i contend city voters turned out in lots fewer % than rural voters; so, imo the above analysis is flawed; it is a debatable topic in my view

Expand full comment
LiberalBuffalo's avatar

Trump picked up 3 million more voters between 2020 and 2024.

Data and polling both tell us they were in a large part low propensity.

Expand full comment
Toiler On the Sea's avatar

Yes but overall turnout was down and Harris lost a more Biden votes than Trump gained from 2020 (millions of blue state D voters stayed home) . . so I don't think anyone can make a clear cut definitive statement either way. I think if we'd had 2020-level turnout Harris would've concievably won the PV if not the EC.

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

agreed; its debatable, not FACT, as stated above

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

im talking about the ones who stayed on their couch

Expand full comment
Jonathan's avatar

im currently watching 4 basketball games; so, if im slow in responding, its not that im ignoring you or anything like that(perhaps we can take this discussion into the weekend open thread?)

Expand full comment
Toiler On the Sea's avatar

In Wisconsin?

Expand full comment
ErrorError