As a Yankees fan, I liked Sabathia but never once thought of him as a Hall of Famer. If he's in the Hall of Fame, how is Guidry out? (To be clear, I don't think Guidry is quite a Hall of Famer by rights, either.) How is a career 3.74 ERA outstanding? Ichiro was a great player, though, and I think his excellence in Japanese baseball as we…
As a Yankees fan, I liked Sabathia but never once thought of him as a Hall of Famer. If he's in the Hall of Fame, how is Guidry out? (To be clear, I don't think Guidry is quite a Hall of Famer by rights, either.) How is a career 3.74 ERA outstanding? Ichiro was a great player, though, and I think his excellence in Japanese baseball as well as the Major Leagues should be taken into account. I think he belongs. He was one of the best throwing outfielders I've ever seen and there were times when it was nearly impossible to pitch to him, plus he had outstanding speed on both sides of the field. He made a big impact on the game.
As a Yankees fan, I liked Sabathia but never once thought of him as a Hall of Famer. If he's in the Hall of Fame, how is Guidry out? (To be clear, I don't think Guidry is quite a Hall of Famer by rights, either.) How is a career 3.74 ERA outstanding? Ichiro was a great player, though, and I think his excellence in Japanese baseball as well as the Major Leagues should be taken into account. I think he belongs. He was one of the best throwing outfielders I've ever seen and there were times when it was nearly impossible to pitch to him, plus he had outstanding speed on both sides of the field. He made a big impact on the game.