7 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Paleo's avatar

A Trump judge ruled there’s a Second Amendment right to own machine guns

https://www.vox.com/scotus/368616/supreme-court-second-amendment-machine-guns-bruen-broomes

Expand full comment
michaelflutist's avatar

Insane! Someone should argue there's a right to own howitzers!

Expand full comment
Avedee Eikew's avatar

I personally won't feel safe until I have the right to an ICBM that obliterates everything in a 10-mile radius.

Expand full comment
Zero Cool's avatar

But there were no machine guns owned by the average American household back in the late 18th century!

This is why the 2nd Amendment needs to be modified or straight out repealed.

Expand full comment
michaelflutist's avatar

Repeal would be the right move. There's no reason gun ownership shouldn't be regulated by statute. But it's very hard to amend the constitution.

Expand full comment
Zero Cool's avatar

The last amendment to the Constitution I believe was the 27th Amendment back in 1992. Since then, we've waited long enough.

The problem is, the 2nd Amendment applied to a much different time in U.S. history and before the Civil War. Considering how much the U.S. has changed since the original amendment, it's still important to educate more of the public on exactly what's in it.

I don't think the gun nuts really understand the 2nd Amendment as much as they think they do.

Expand full comment
michaelflutist's avatar

In that case, though, neither does the Supreme Court. Listen, I think it's completely absurd for there to be a constitutional right to own a gun. I wouldn't prohibit all gun ownership, but it should be regulated by statute, just like driving. So I'm all for a constitutional amendment that repeals the right to own any weaponry and authorizes Congress, state legislatures and city councils to pass any law they like that sets standards for regulating arms ownership. I just think it's wildly optimistic to believe we could get such an amendment through the requisite number of state legislatures, even when Congress would agree to it, and that's also quite far off.

Expand full comment
ErrorError